The U.S. and International Law in Changing Times: The International Law Section’s 2-day Conference
17th December 2025
Solon Solomon (Associate Professor, BUL) and Saeed Bagheri (Assistant Professor, University of Reading)
On 5-6 November 2025, the SLS International Law section and Solon Solomon (BUL), together with Saeed Bagheri (University of Reading), organised an international conference titled ‘The U.S. and International Law in Changing Times’. The 2-day Conference took place at the Institute of Advanced Legal Studies and at BUL and saw Professors Jose Alvarez (NYU) and Oona Hathaway (Yale) delivering keynote addresses as well as participating in a roundtable discussion moderated by Solon Solomon and joined by Professors Martins Paparinskis (UCL & Chair of the UN International Law Commission) and Moshe Hirsch (The Hebrew University of Jerusalem)(see here).
Introduced by Iris Anastasiadou from the British Institute of International and Comparative Law, Solon Solomon (see here) opened the Conference with a short opening speech where he stressed how the new U.S. administration has rattled the waters of international law, calling us to rethink whether in all cases we are talking about violations of the existing legal norms or attempts to reshape them, with the synergy also of other States in the international community. Moreover, Solomon stressed that the current U.S. approach to international law invites a broader discussion about international law’s functionality, especially regarding UN organs such as the Human Rights Council and the evidence procedure before the International Court of Justice.
The Conference’s first panel discussed the theme of the U.S. in a changing world. Chaired by Professor Javaid Rehman (BUL), the panel saw Professor Alberto Costi from the Victoria University of Wellington explaining how the U.S. policy vis-à-vis the Pacific islands created conflicting views between the U.S. and these islands on international law issues (e.g., climate change), as well as introducing wider geopolitical questions regarding the clash of interests between the U.S. and China in the particular part of the world. Professor Achilles Skordas (Max Planck Institute) focused on the U.S. role in a changing world when it comes to the Middle East, arguing that any future Palestinian state must be ready to integrate peacefully in the region and underlining how the existing U.S.-led Abraham Accords can play a role to this extent. Staying on the importance of the geostrategic role the U.S. plays in shaping international law, Max Yoeli from Chatham House underscored how this role can reshape the broader international relations landscape. The panel closed with a presentation by Eric Loefflad (University of Kent), who noted that what we see today is the transformation of the U.S. global role from a superpower to a regional power. Loefflad proceeded to analyse how this impacts the stance the U.S. undertakes towards international law.
The second panel, chaired by Colin Luoma (BUL), focused on human rights. A number of presenters highlighted how the current U.S. policy presents challenges or violates established human rights norms. Professor Ruvi Ziegler (University of Reading) discussed this in the context of refugee law. At the same time, Ronit Levine (Tel Aviv University) focused on the recently enacted enmity law in the United States and how it provides a broad platform for an organisation to be designated as an ‘enemy’ by the U.S. administration. Max Hillaire, visiting Professor at Charles University in Prague, discussed in detail international human rights litigation before U.S. courts. On this account, Yifan Jia (King’s College London) focused on the question of whether the adoption of the US Global Magnitsky Human Rights Accountability Act in 2016, instituting sanctions against individuals and entities responsible for gross human rights violations, ultimately complements or undermines the existing human rights protection framework.
Following lunch, the Conference resumed with Professor Oona Hathaway rendering her keynote address on the past, present and future of the global legal order. Professor Hathaway focused on how under the old-world order, conquest, and ‘gunboat diplomacy’ (meaning the imposition of a State’s political will through force) were accepted as legal. Moreover, neutrality required total impartiality (economic sanctions by neutrals were illegal) and there was no such thing as a crime of aggression. Whereas all of this had changed following the 1928 Kellogg-Briand Pact outlawing war, a commitment reaffirmed in the United Nations Charter. At present, this shift is under threat, as the prohibition on war is under unprecedented pressure. The threats come not only from the U.S. but also from its main rival throughout the Cold War – Russia – leading to fears that if China also follows this path, we may end up in a world where the three major powers will carve for themselves zones of influence. Professor Hathaway had the opportunity to elaborate on her stance also in the roundtable that followed. She then had the opportunity to respond to questions by the press, such as that posed by The Guardian’s diplomatic editor Patrick Wintour, who later reported Hathaway’s stance in a Guardian piece (see here).
In coming to discuss whether the U.S. current stance towards international law should be seen as an attempt to revisit and rewrite some of the international norms or just a violation of the latter, Professor Hathaway was joined by Professor Alvarez, who also underlined how the U.S. policy is unpredictable and ultimately problematic regarding the rule of law. Professor Paparinskis took the discussion to the level of the UN International Law Commission, discussing how the U.S. acts as one of many international players within the specific body and also in the broader global arena. Then, Professor Hirsch focused on the WTO, delineating how U.S. policy towards the body epitomised a realpolitik approach.
The second day of the Conference opened at BUL with a welcome speech by Professor Joshua Castellino, Head of the BUL College for Arts, Law and Social Sciences. Referring to his latest book, Professor Castellino underlined the importance of international law for resolving international disputes and addressing today’s pressing problems in the international community. Consequently, the floor was given to Professor Malgosia Fitzmaurice (Queen Mary University of London), who delineated the U.S. stance on the law of the sea and the question of whether the U.S. has an international law obligation to reduce greenhouse gas emissions from shipping. Giving an eloquent address and drawing from her longstanding expertise in the law of the sea, Professor Fitzmaurice underlined this obligation under customary law. In turn, Professor Kimberly Breedon from the Ohio Northern University discussed the panel’s wider theme of whether the U.S. is reshaping international law, focusing on the concept of immunities and discussing how the Trump v United States Supreme Court decision can have implications on the way international law looks and operates.
Subsequent presentations focused on U.S. policy in two distinct legal fields: outer space law and international trade law. Regarding outer space law, Berna Akcali (Queen Mary University of London) discussed how, through the Artemis Accords, the U.S. is reshaping the law to entrench its presence in outer space. From their part, Professors Jeffrey Dunoff and Mark Polack (Temple University) focused on the Trump administration’s trade deals, explaining their nature, rationale, and implications for the current international legal landscape.
The Conference then featured Professor Jose Alvarez delivering the second keynote address. Professor Alvarez analysed the origins and essence of the ‘America First’ doctrine that pervades the current U.S. administration agenda and described how actions undertaken by the latter in the name of this doctrine have led to violations of the international law status quo in fields like the use of force, refugee law or treaty law, and in matters such as climate change and deep seabed mining. Professor Alvarez’s address was attended not only by the Conference’s deputies but also by BUL students, who asked questions and engaged with the speaker.
Following lunch, the Conference convened again, this time for a panel chaired by Saeed Bagheri, the U.S. policy in matters concerning AI, science and technology. Rossana de Plano (Leicester University) concentrated on U.S. space policy. Meanwhile, Fabio Tronchetti (Northumbria University) expanded on the U.S. goal of integrating AI to ensure space dominance. Tanaka Mparutsa (University of Cape Town) examined the U.S. policy towards AI, also beyond space law, arguing how the signing of the Executive Order 14179 by President Trump aspires to render a leadership role to the U.S. in the field and normatively shape international responses. Finally, Daryna Abbakumova (Graduate Institute of Geneva), examined the U.S. policy towards AI from a law-of-war perspective. In particular, Abbakumova argued that the U.S. should develop a more concise policy on whether civilian data should be treated as a civilian object under the laws of war or as a legitimate military target.
The next panel, chaired by Filip Balcerzak (BUL), delved into U.S. policy on trade law matters. Panel member Renée Robinson (Paris I-Pantheon Sorbonne) discussed tariffs as transnational harms, highlighting the impact on women working in cloth factories in Bangladesh, Sri Lanka, and Cambodia. She explained that the current system of advisory opinions before the ICJ could be applied to trade-related harms, as it has been for climate change damages. Gunjan Sharma from Volterra Fietta highlighted this in his presentation, while Xenia Seabright (University of Vienna) discussed how the U.S.-China tariff rivalry has politicised finance and its implications for the role of international organisations and the broader rule of law.
The fourth session of the day focused on the role of the U.S. in international organisations, most notably the two international courts with universal jurisdiction, the International Court of Justice and the International Criminal Court. Chaired by Saeed Bagheri, the session saw Courtney Grafton (20 Essex Chambers), Marco Longobardo (University of Westminster), and Giulia Pecorella (Middlesex University) discussing the U.S. sanctions towards the International Criminal Court and whether these sanctions should be seen as a continuation of an established U.S. policy towards the court or in conjunction with the U.S. position on the International Court of Justice.
The Conference ended with Saeed Bagheri highlighting that international law is a dynamic, evolving project influenced by global change and actions of powerful states like the U.S. He observed that across different panels on geopolitics, human rights, technology, trade, and multilateralism, a central theme was the need for the U.S. to align its influence with international norms, showing that leadership and legality can support each other. He expressed gratitude to participants and highlighted that the future of international law depends on collective realism, humility, and imagination. In turn, Bagheri gave the podium to Professor Gerry Simpson (LSE) for the closing address. In that, Professor Simpson emphasised the importance of a rules-based international community, citing Prosper Weil’s article in the American Journal of International Law to discuss international law’s relative normativity and its impact on the current U.S. stance towards international legal norms. In that sense, Professor Simpson offered his concluding remarks as an effort to disentangle how the various ends of international law figured or prefigured in the present crisis.
The Conference ended with drinks at the BUL campus, kindly sponsored by an anonymous BUL sponsor, leaving participants with a lasting impression and words of encouragement for the SLS and the International Law section to continue organising similar events.
