Home > Blog > Uncategorised > What Is the Purpose of a Law Degree? AI In Contract Law Pedagogy from an EDI Perspective

What Is the Purpose of a Law Degree? AI In Contract Law Pedagogy from an EDI Perspective

3rd June 2026

Dr Gift Sotonye-Frank (Queen’s University Belfast; g.sotonye@qub.ac.uk)

Too often, students use of generative AI (AI) is framed narrowly in terms of academic misconduct. However, this conference sought to go beyond this narrow conception of how AI is used. In particular, we examined how legal educators, students, and practitioners are using or engaging with AI in order to shift the narrative from one of prohibition to one of accountability and critical awareness.

On 20 March 2026 scholars from across the globe gathered at the conference organised by Dr Gift Sotonye-Frank and Prof. David Capper, titled ‘AI in Contract Law Pedagogy-An EDI Perspective’ held at Queen’s University Belfast. At the start of the conference, a student participant set the tone for the day by asking the question: what is the purpose of a Law degree? This question was thought provoking due to the rapid emergence of AI reshaping legal practice, thus raising important questions about how law schools should respond. The objective of the conference was to provide space for conversation and knowledge exchange about AI integration in legal education more broadly but using contract law as a case study, because it lends itself to how AI can be embedded across foundational legal subjects in an effective, ethical and inclusive manner. What emerged from the papers and discussions was not a single answer, but a rich and necessary dialogue about the future of legal education.

Quick Overview of the Conference Papers

It is common knowledge that AI is already transforming how legal tasks are performed. From drafting contractual clauses to summarising case law, Gen AI tools are used to accelerate routine processes and reduce technical errors. That said, within the classroom, this presents an opportunity for introducing students to responsible and ethical use of AI. Dr Liam Sunner’s paper, ‘Teaching Generative AI to write a contract for me? Engaging in contract creation using Generative AI’, explored the pedagogical use of AI in legal education through a classroom exercise. It was focused on supporting learning beyond the narrative of ‘prohibition’ but with a view to expose students to the limitations that exist in the legal context

With limited contact hours and an increasing reliance on independent learning, the integration of AI invites reflection on whether students perceive their education as a process of intellectual development or simply a pathway to certification. These issues are particularly pressing in the context of AI, where efficiency gains may risk reinforcing surface-level engagement unless they are carefully structured within pedagogical design. The paper by Dr Niamh Connolly, Olina Tian, Mishal Ursani and Karen Youakim (UCL), ‘An empirical study of law students’ views on the use of AI in learning and assessment’, addressed some of these key issues. The key question for these authors was exploring what students believe is the purpose of their law degree. Their thought-provoking empirical research revealed that students have views about how AI is shaping their legal education.

Prof. Genival Silva Souzo Filho’s (University of São Paulo) paper titled, ‘AI and the Social Function of Legal Education: Digital Contract Practice Supporting Vulnerable Entrepreneurs in Brazil’, focused on how AI assisted digital contract practice expands access to legal knowledge and to basic transactional security in contexts marked by structural poverty, low state presence and minimal professional legal support for small entrepreneurs operating in informal commercial ecosystems. It focused in on the Favelas of south eastern Brazil. In particular Dr Genival explained how classroom activities enable students to work with AI supported contract drafting in ways that are practical and solution driven for vulnerable entrepreneurs in the region.

My paper, titled ‘From Doctrine to Digital Practice: Integrating Generative AI in Contract Law through Flipped Pedagogy and Employer Collaboration’, provided insight into how AI tools are used to design flipped classroom structured learning environments with pre-class tasks, so that lecture time is used for collaborative, peer-led problem solving, where students apply doctrinal principles to complex scenarios. My emphasis was on how this approach provided a varied learning pace and an enhanced student engagement in the classroom,  for better understanding of complex legal concepts in contract law.

Highlighted in the paper, ‘Embedding Critical Pedagogy in Contract Law through AI of Un-Ordinary Prudence’, by Dr Shahab Saquib (Birmingham) was the argument that the use of AI driven chatbots based on leading contract law cases, enables students to interact with doctrinal concepts in new ways. Consequently, these students can relate contract law knowledge to real-world contexts through the use of AI-supported tools.

Dr Ilona Schembri argued in, ‘AI Can Draft, Lawyers Must Decide’, that the idea that the pedagogical value of AI in contract law lies precisely in understanding its limits, and that such limits are shaped by the identity of the parties, commercial objectives, risk allocation, bargaining power, and the applicable law. As a consequence, AI systems, due to their inherent inability to function without the datasets fed to them, cannot replace legal reasoning but can serve as a complementary pedagogical tool.

Keynote speakers, Lee Hansen and Dr Eoin O’Dell focused on how the intrinsic fallibility of large language models (LLMs) may be used constructively to enhance the teaching and learning of contract law. Building on errorful learning theory, Lee Hansen emphasised how student-shaped error engagement with such mistakes can promote deeper critical thinking, doctrinal understanding, and reflective legal analysis.

In conclusion, it is undoubtedly clear that the integration of AI into legal education requires careful consideration of how the tools are used, what learning outcomes are prioritised, and how students are prepared for the realities of legal practice. Significantly, the importance of fostering ongoing critical dialogue cannot be over emphasised. Indeed, AI should neither be uncritically embraced nor outright rejected. Instead, it must be engaged with thoughtfully, with attention to its implications for doctrinal learning, professional identity, and inclusion.

Leave a Reply