Home > Blog > Uncategorised > The role of EU agencies in protecting vulnerable migrants against human trafficking

The role of EU agencies in protecting vulnerable migrants against human trafficking

30th January 2025

Dr Matilde Ventrella, Senior Lecturer in law, Liverpool John Moores University and Professor Sonia Morano-Foadi, Oxford Brookes University

Our research, which has been funded by the SLS Activity Fund, investigates the role of the EU agencies in protecting actual and potential victims of human trafficking entering the EU. This study builds on previous work supported by Oxford Brookes University (OBU), which explored the role of Frontex in identifying human trafficking victims stranded at sea. The OBU research stemmed from a 2022 co-authored article, ‘Out of sight, out of mind. Reassessing positive obligations towards victims of human trafficking’, which was published in The Journal of Immigration, Asylum and Nationality Law in 2022. This earlier work highlighted the gaps in identifying and supporting trafficking victims, prompting the need for further exploration into the roles and responsibilities of Justice and Home Affairs (JHA) agencies in combating trafficking.

This SLS-funded study is particularly timely as it aligns with the recent reforms introduced by the Pact on Migration and Asylum, adopted in June 2024 and slated for implementation over the next two years. A key feature of the Pact is the operational and financial support provided to EU Member States by dedicated EU funds and six decentralised EU agencies, including Frontex, EUAA and the Research Executive Agency (REA). These agencies play a pivotal role in addressing diverse home affairs issues, including migration and border management, drug trafficking, organised crime, and human trafficking. Although human trafficking falls within the agencies’ mandate, the identification of victims and potential victims of trafficking is often not prioritised. This process should take place even before criminal investigations are initiated and should also extend extraterritorially to include migrants stranded in international waters near the borders of EU Member States. Building on this foundation, our SLS-funded research further examines the specific roles JHA agencies play in identifying and safeguarding human trafficking victims and those at risk. A key output of this research is a mapping exercise evaluating the JHA agency’s role in protecting vulnerable migrants from human trafficking.

As part of the OBU internal funding, an expert meeting was held at the European Border and Coast Guard Agency (Frontex) in Warsaw in March 2024. This meeting provided valuable insights into Frontex’s mandate, particularly the role of its Fundamental Rights Office (FRO) in protecting trafficking victims and monitoring human rights compliance. The findings from this meeting were published in a co-authored article, ‘Agencification, Fundamental Rights and the non-Delegation Doctrine: Frontex’s Mandate on Trafficking in Human Beings (THB)’ (2024), in the Yearbook of European Union and Comparative Law.

Building on this momentum, with the grant received by the SLS, we organised another expert meeting with the European Union Agency for Asylum (EUAA) in Malta, gathering further data to be analysed in a forthcoming publication. Through our research, we are discovering that JHA agencies present themselves as having only a marginal role in the identification of victims and potential victims of human trafficking.

Efforts to engage other JHA agencies have faced challenges. Attempts to organise meetings with Europol and Eurojust were ultimately unsuccessful. Europol declined outright, while Eurojust initially accepted but withdrew shortly before the scheduled meeting. These setbacks underscore difficulties in fostering inter-agency cooperation on trafficking-related issues, particularly from a human rights perspective.

Collaboration with NGOs has been a vital aspect of this research. Suzanne Hoff, the coordinator of La Strada International,  a leading NGO based in Amsterdam, has provided practical expertise and has also accompanied the research team to several expert meetings. She noted that the 2022 article had a positive impact on the NGO’s advocacy efforts, reinforcing the relevance of the research in bridging academic work with practical interventions. Mrs Hoff stated:

“We have also worked with PICUM [Platform for Undocumented Migrants] and others on the possible connections between smuggling and trafficking, to build an evidence base for influencing national EU governments to ensure identification of potential victims of human trafficking among smuggled migrants, as discerned from our grass root work at regular level. Indeed the identification and protection of victims is also our main priority which comes before investigations on perpetrators. So to conclude, we will be using your research findings to further advocate for the rights of victims we assist and to influence policies that can enhance these rights”.

While challenges in securing cooperation from some agencies persist, we remain committed to exploring ways to expand the roles and responsibilities of JHA agencies in combating human trafficking effectively.

Looking ahead, the team plans to conduct an expert meeting with the EU Fundamental Rights Agency (FRA) and continue publishing findings to influence both policy and practice.

Leave a Reply