The Influence of Social Identity and Rhetoric in Athenian Trials
7th November 2024
The perception of classical Athenian trials as straightforward judicial processes centred on facts and legal principles is increasingly being challenged. Recent scholarship reveals a more complex reality. My recent article, “Mind the Audience: Forensic Rhetoric, Persuasion, and Identification by Reference to the Social Identity of Athenian dikastai”, in Rhetorica, explores the complexities of forensic rhetoric in Athenian courts. The research was made possible through the SLS Research Activities Fund. The article highlights that litigants did not merely present and exclusively focus on legal arguments; instead, they strategically appealed to the social identities and values of the jurors, known as dikastai, using group psychology and persuasive rhetoric to influence verdicts.
The Social Identity of Athenian Jurors
Athenian jurors, composed of ordinary male citizens over 30 selected by lot, operated without a professional judge, undertaking the roles of both judge and jury without specialised legal training. Despite their diversity, these jurors shared a strong social identity rooted in their Athenian citizenship. They considered themselves defenders of the city’s values and traditions, which fostered a cohesive group identity. This shared identity made them particularly receptive to arguments resonating with their collective values—a concept Kenneth Burke describes as “identification”. According to Burke, individuals are more likely to be persuaded when they perceive an intrinsic alignment with the speaker.
Identification and Division in Athenian Rhetoric
Litigants in Athenian courts often employed the strategy of “identification” to connect with jurors’ sense of self. They developed narratives aligning their own identities with the values upheld by the dikastai, portraying themselves as embodiments of Athenian ideals while characterising their opponents as outsiders or transgressors. For instance, litigants invoked connections to revered figures such as Solon, Athens’ esteemed lawmaker, to assert their commitment to justice and civic responsibility. By referencing Solon, they implied that their opponents’ actions deviated from Athenian norms.
This approach reinforced notions of ingroup and outgroup reasoning. By framing adversaries as part of an “outgroup” or as violators of Athenian norms, litigants created a stark moral dichotomy, prompting jurors to view them as ethical counterparts to their adversaries.
Utilising Prototypes and Social Psychology in Arguments
Litigants constructed narratives adhering to prototypical Athenian traits, representing the “ideal” Athenian citizen from the dikastai’s perspective. By presenting themselves as models of these traits, litigants strengthened their position within the collective Athenian identity, portraying opponents as morally deficient or subversive to the social order.
A common rhetorical tactic involved referencing the achievements of heroic Athenian ancestors, urging jurors to act in accordance with those ideals. For example, Lycurgus, in his case against Leocrates, invoked the heroism of Athenian ancestors who defended the city against the Persians, implicitly shaming his opponent’s ostensible lack of patriotism amounting to treason. By invoking the ancestors and other legendary figures, Lycurgus portrayed Leocrates as cowardly and implied that not convicting him would tarnish the legacy of Athens’ heroes.
The Impact of Social Identity Theory on Juror Bias
Social Identity Theory provides insight into how these rhetorical strategies could influence dikastai decisions. This theory suggests that individuals derive their identity from group memberships, often conforming to group norms and exhibiting favouritism toward those reflecting the group’s values. In the context of Athenian courts, jurors may have felt inclined to favour litigants aligned with Athenian ideals, viewing them as embodiments of their own identity and beliefs. This dynamic created potential for bias, where emotional appeals to group identity possibly overshadowed objective assessments. According to Social Identity Theory, in cases with ambiguous evidence, jurors are more likely to rely on heuristic processing, employing cognitive shortcuts drawn from social identity and stereotypes.
Athenian Courts as Arenas for Social Conformity
Rather than viewing Athenian trials as purely judicial processes, they most likely functioned as mechanisms for enforcing social conformity. Litigants aimed to demonstrate that their interpretations aligned with Athenian identity while their opponents diverged. Essentially, the courts did not merely resolve disputes; they reinforced social norms by rewarding conformity and penalising deviance.
Litigants often asked for the imposition of the “majority stance”, arguing that their perspectives reflected the majority view. By framing their stance as widely accepted among the Athenian populace, litigants pressured the dikastai to conform to group norms, invoking the power of collective identity to promote solidarity. This strategy was supported by references to precedent and tradition, establishing continuity between the jury’s decisions and those of past jurors, thereby reinforcing a consistent Athenian identity.
Lessons from Ancient Rhetoric
These findings illuminate the significant role of social identity in shaping judicial outcomes, both in ancient Athens and potentially in contemporary contexts. The study illustrates occasions in which effective persuasion supplements (or even transcends) logical argumentation, building the audience’s values and identities. Understanding these rhetorical techniques offers valuable insights into how social dynamics and identity influence not only Athenian legal proceedings but also modern political and judicial processes.
In today’s context, where group identities significantly influence decision-making, it is crucial for politicians, advocates, and public speakers to understand these dynamics. As exploration continues at the intersection of rhetoric, identity, and law, there is much to learn from the persuasive strategies that shaped the justice system of ancient Athens.
Vasileios Adamidis PhD, SFHEA
Associate Professor, Nottingham Law School
