Home > Blog > Uncategorised > Digitalisation of trade documents: law and business

Digitalisation of trade documents: law and business

19th September 2024

Liang Zhao, University of Southampton Law School

The United Nations Commission on International Trade Law (UNCITRAL) published the Model Law on Electronic Transferable Records (Model Law) in 2017. According to the Model Law, an electronic negotiable trade document is functionally equivalent to a transferable paper document if a reliable method is used for exclusive control of the electronic document. In 2021, Singapore amended their Electronic Transactions Act 2010 (amended ETA 2010) to adopt the Model Law with only minor modifications. The UK Electronic Trade Documents Act 2023 (ETDA 2023) also requires a reliable system for recognition of the legal effect of electronic trade documents.

However, it is unknown what designates a system as ‘reliable’ under the UK’s 2023 Act.  This brings uncertainty when considering the law. It is believed that the reliability requirement in the ETDA 2023 is the biggest challenge to widespread adoption of electronic trade documents. More importantly, different digital platforms have different contractual frameworks. Digitalisation of trade documents cannot be sustainably achieved if there is no legal interoperability of different frameworks across different electronic platforms. Two of the main objectives of my research visit are to investigate how a reliable system is established under the new legal regime by digital trade platforms, and also investigate how the legal interoperability across electronic platforms is achieved.

The current electronic platforms are contact-based. The contractual solution for the legal effect of electronic trade documents is that all parties agree to recognise or not deny the legal effect of the trade documents in electronic systems under a multi-party contractual framework. Before the 2023 legislation, the reliability of electronic bill of lading systems was guaranteed by the International Group of P&I Clubs (the Group), representing the 12 P&I Clubs which insure 90% of the world’s ocean-going tonnage. The Group has approved ten electronic platforms/systems which have been running since 2010. After passage of the ETDA 2023, electronic platforms need to examine their systems to comply with the requirement of reliability so that electronic documents in the systems can be legally recognised by law.

Singapore is the only developed shipping and trade country that has adopted the Model law. Singapore has the most (four out of ten) approved platforms which have established headquarters or branches for operation of electronic platforms. Singapore has developed a TradeTrust platform, which provides solutions to resolve issues of legal and technical interoperability. Therefore, Singapore is an optimal place for legal researchers to obtain a case study investigating reliable systems, which is relevant for implementation of the ETDA 2023 and digitalisation of international trade documents.

I applied for the SLS’s RAF for a research visit to continue my case study on electronic trade documents in electronic platforms in Singapore. The electronic platforms include E-Title, Bolero, TradeGo, ICE CargoDocs and TradeTrust which are successful platforms for digital trade. With the financial support of SLS’s RAF, I completed my research visit to Singapore in June 2024. I observed the operation of their electronic systems, studied real cases of electronic trade document transactions, and examined their legal frameworks for establishing reliable systems. I also visited the Centre for Maritime Law (CML) at the National University of Singapore Faculty of Law. I delivered a seminar at NUS on my research to legal experts, and compared English law with the law of Singapore for digitalisation of trade documents.

This research aims to investigate the current contractual framework and legal interoperability, examining whether and how the digitalisation of trade documents can be achieved under the new legal regime of the ETDA 2023. This is original and innovative research under the new legal regime which has never been done before. The use of future electronic trade documents will promote sustainable development of trade by reducing the shipping and trade industries’ carbon footprint. The outcome of this research will enhance the influence of English law on international trade and will contribute to the legal development regarding the digitalisation of international trade.

 

Leave a Reply