Home > Blog > Uncategorised > Shifting the Place of Social Security: Blog by Jed Meers, Joint-Winner of the 2016 Poster Prize

Shifting the Place of Social Security: Blog by Jed Meers, Joint-Winner of the 2016 Poster Prize

21st September 2016

Jed Meers is a PhD student at York Law School, looking at housing law and welfare reform.

 artboard-1

Shifting the Place of Social Security: Blog by Joint-Winner of the 2016 Poster Prize

 

Academic posters still receive some mixed press. So much so, a Routledge Handbook published earlier this year dedicates a chapter to asking, “The Academic Poster: Friend or Foe?” The author highlights problems still linked with the medium: its association with a lack of prestige, conference organisers not allowing space or time to display and disseminate them, or – apparently, when compared to some other disciplines – the predisposition of lawyers to design posters using “a simple copy and paste operation from the paper.” She suggests that when the sessions are well organised and publicised, academic posters have the potential to be effective ways to communicate research findings or ongoing projects.

 

Notwithstanding some less anecdotal evidence available on the merits of poster presentations, my own experience from the SLS conference this year is that the organisers have given a great deal of attention to getting the most out of the poster sessions. A total of 29 posters were on display across the conference, separated into two sections, each with a dedicated time in the programme for authors and delegates to attend and ask/answer questions. The sessions were well-attended, and I found the opportunity to discuss the research on a one-to-one basis (without any amber or red cards flashing a time warning) was really valuable.

 

Uploaded posters are still available to look through online at the SLS Paperbank. Some of my personal favourites include Rebecca Moosavian’s (hand drawn!) poster on “Power/Knowledge Dynamics in the Iraq War”, Crompton et al’s dendroid “Legislation and the role of the Judiciary: Students as Supreme Court Justices”, and Guido Noto La Diega’s “IPREXIT: Intellectual property after the EU referendum” (who has managed the remarkable feat of including pictures of both Pikachu and Theresa May on the same poster).

 

So I can certainly encourage delegates who may not ordinarily consider submitting a poster to the conference to check out those available online, and to consider submitting their own at Dublin.

 

“Shifting the Place of Social Security”

 

My own poster – “Shifting the Place of Social Security: Social Rights under Austerity in the UK” – is based on the findings of a national report on Welfare Reform and Social Rights in the UK. The project website – www.socialrights.co.uk – provides some further details, a blog on current developments, and links to a parallel Italian case study.

 

It puts forward a condensed form of the arguments contained in an associated book chapter, which looks at judicial review challenges following the UK Coalition Government’s Welfare Reform Act 2012. It argues that there are four key themes which emerged in the challenges to these polices – some of the most (in)famous being the benefit cap and so-called “bedroom tax”: (i) the increasing role ascribed to administrative discretion, (ii) the neglect (and difficulty in challenging) cumulative impact, (iii) the heavy reliance within the UK constitution on discrimination-based challenges, and (iv) the weight attached within proportionality assessments to a vehicular articulation of “austerity.”

 

Half of the poster focuses more explicitly on the first of these, depicting the particular problem of Discretionary Housing Payments, availability of which featured heavily in appeals to the Benefit Cap and especially the so-called “bedroom tax.” Here, the Court is forced into a position of assessing the relative difference between those subject to statutory exemption, and those who are reliant on the provision of these top-up payments. The argument the poster makes is that the latter are in a substantively inferior position to the former, and this is depicted through an annotated “discretionary assault course”, which some claimants have to navigate to secure adequate provision of benefits to which they would otherwise be statutorily entitled.

 

If this sort of area is of interest, we also carry a blog on the SocialRights.co.uk website, including posts from a range of guest authors. Our most recent post – by Byron Karemba (University of Leeds) – looks at the UK Supreme Court’s increasing involvement in cases dealing with public resource allocation.

 

 

Leave a Reply