Home > Blog > Uncategorised > Latest @UKSupremeCourt Judgments

Latest @UKSupremeCourt Judgments

6th July 2016

The Supreme Court has decided two cases today.

In R (on the application of Ismail) (Respondent) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2016] UKSC 37 (https://www.supremecourt.uk/cases/docs/uksc-2013-0160-judgment.pdf), the Court holds that, on the facts, service of a foreign judgment under section 1 of the Crime (International Co-operation) Act 2003 would not amount to a possible breach of art 6 rights. As Lord Kerr puts it,

[36] ‘The decision of the Secretary of State to serve the judgment on him did not expose him to the risk of violation of his Convention rights. It is undoubtedly true that service of the judgment would have placed Mr Ismail in something of a dilemma. But it is no part of the Secretary of State’s function to take steps to relieve him of the need to confront that dilemma. Avoidance of the consequences of the judgment becoming final lay in Mr Ismail’s hands. He could – as he did – simply decide not to return to Egypt. That may not have been a pleasant prospect but it is a very far cry from saying that his having to face it amounted to a possible violation of his article 6 rights.’

The case may be of interest to members of our Public Law, International Law, Criminal Justice and Civil Liberties & Human Rights Subject Sections.

The second case, Campbell v Gordon [2016] UKSC 38 (https://www.supremecourt.uk/cases/docs/uksc-2015-0061-judgment.pdf), is an appeal from Scotland and concerns employer’s liability insurance (or the absence of it). It may be of interest in particular to our Tort members, although the points it raises about statutory interpretation are of wider interest too. The Court divides 3:2 (Lord Toulson and Lady Hale DPSC dissenting) in ruling that it is not possible to hold an individual director liable for breach of statutory duty in failing to ensure that a company maintained adequate employer’s liability insurance.

Leave a Reply