Home > Blog > Uncategorised > Two New Decisions of the UK Supreme Court: Summary for Members

Two New Decisions of the UK Supreme Court: Summary for Members

30th June 2016

The UK Supreme Court yesterday gave two judgments. In this post, a new proposed series, we offer a brief summary of the decisions on the basis that they may be of interest to members of the Society.

R (on the application of Bancoult (No 2)) v Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs [2016] UKSC 35 (https://www.supremecourt.uk/cases/docs/uksc-2015-0021-judgment.pdf) is the latest in the long-running litigation between the UK Government and the Chagossians, former inhabitants of the Chagos Islands. It may be of particular interest to members of our Civil liberties & Human Rights, Comparative Law, Legal History and Public Law Subject Sections. The Supreme Court had to consider whether to set aside the judgment of the House of Lords in an earlier stage of the litigation (R (Bancoult) v Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs (No 2) [2008] UKHL 6) on the basis of non-disclosure by the UK Government of potentially relevant documents. By a majority of 3:2 (Lords Mance, Neuberger PSC and Clarke in the majority; Lord Kerr and Lady Hale DPSC in the minority), the Supreme Court declines to set aside the 2008 judgment of the House of Lords. The main thrust of the reasoning is that, although the Court has inherent jurisdiction to set aside a judgment in the case of an unfair procedure having been followed, there must be a possibility for the court then to have taken a different view. There is also discussion of the renewed possibility of resettlement of the Chagossians in the light of new circusmtances and whether the present challenge is therefore moot. Lord Kerr’s dissent is principally on the basis that there was a real possibility that a different outcome would have been reached by the court had the non-disclosure not occurred. It is worth noting that Lord Mance (with Lord Bingham) had been a dissentient in the original House of Lords decision, as his Lordship recognised at [2]:

I have not changed my opinion as to what would have been the appropriate outcome of the appeal to the House of Lords. But that is not the issue before us. The issue before us is whether the majority decision should be set aside, not on the grounds that it was wrong in law, but on grounds that the Secretary of State failed, in breach of his duty of candour in public law proceedings, to disclose relevant documents containing information which it is said would have been likely to have affected the factual basis on which the House proceeded.

Lady Hale concludes her dissent by observing (at 194):

Ultimately, this is a case about justice. While I deeply admire the industry and intellectual honesty of Lord Mance, which has led him to the conclusion that the decision with which he disagreed at the time should not be set aside, for the reasons given by Lord Kerr, with which I agree, I would grant this application. Justice to my mind demands that the applicant be given a fair chance to satisfy this court that the decision to re-impose the denial of the islanders’ right of abode was not a rational one

 

The other case decided yesterday concerned the conjoined appeals in Goluchowski v District Court in Elblag and Poland Sasv Circuit Court in Zielona Gora and District Court in Jelenia Gora, Poland [2016] UKSC 36 (https://www.supremecourt.uk/cases/docs/uksc-2015-0073-judgment.pdf). The Court here considers European Arrest Warrants (EAWs) and the case may be of particular interest to members of our Civil Liberties & Human Rights, EU and Competition Law and Criminal Justice Subject Sections. Both appellants had already been convicted and were wanted for the purpose of serving their sentences in prison – the sentence of imprisonment did not take immediate effect. The appellants had appealed on the basis that EAWs in their cases were allegedly defective under s2(6)(c) of the Extradition Act 2003, as they did not detail all warrants and summonses which had been issued in Poland in the attempts to find them within the jurisdiction. The Supreme Court, for whom Lord Mance gives the leading judgment with a shorting concurring judgment by Lord Neuberger, unanimously held that the EAWs were not defective. The Court’s focus is on ‘conviction cases’ rather than ‘accusation cases’ (the latter being where the extradited person is still to face a trial). The summonses and warrants issued were all in connection with trying to find the defendants in order that they should serve the terms of imprisonment to which they had already been sentenced: it was not necessary to detail the full case history in the EAW. Lord Mance (with Lord Neuberger) clarify that Lord Sumption’s remarks in Zakrzewski v District Court in Torun, Poland [2013] 1 WLR 324 ‘should not be taken as representing some sort of absolute rule that the facts in an EAW must be assumed to be correct by the courts of the executing state in every case, irrespective of the evidence’ (Lord Neuberger, para 52).

Leave a Reply