Home > Speech at President’s Reception 2025

Speech at President’s Reception 2025

It is an honour to address you as the President of the Society of Legal Scholars for the 2024-2025 academic year, and to host the Society’s annual conference at the University of Leeds from 2-4 September 2025. My first SLS conference in 1999 was in fact at the University of Leeds, under the Presidency of Professor John Bell. Law has been taught at Leeds since 1899, ten years before the Society was founded, when an annual grant of £450 was received from the Yorkshire Board of Legal Studies. Much has changed both at Leeds and in the Society. For one, it is no longer true that all our students at Leeds are male, part-time, or from the local area – and there are a lot more than 22 of them. Much has changed with the Society as well as is clear from a cursory look at the history of the Society written by Fiona Cownie and Raymond Cocks, ‘A Great and Noble Occupation’: The History of the Society of Legal Scholars (Hart, 2009). Even over the last 25 years of my own involvement with the Society plenty has changed.

It is interesting to reflect therefore on similarities and differences for a moment. Clearly, our forebears in the 1910s and 1920s would have been bemused at the idea of an ‘online’ meeting and the question of how to deal with artificial intelligence and students’ use of ChatGPT and similar systems would have been utterly baffling. The Society has also changed its name. Thankfully, we are no longer debating whether to admit women to the Society and we have a vibrant and active Equality, Diversity, and Inclusion Committee, currently chaired by Professor Claudina Richards of the University of East Anglia, who combines that role with the Vice-Presidency of the Society.

However, the concerns that legal academics and the Society were dealing with were quite similar then and now even as technology and society have moved on. Before the Society of Public Teachers of Law (as it was initially named) was formed, Edward Jenks wrote to a small group of colleagues, proposing that such a Society be set up and received a positive response from figures such as Walter Copinger, then teaching at Manchester and an expert on copyright law who lent his name to Copinger and Skone James on Copyright currently in its nineteenth (2024) edition. A letter was then sent to professors and lecturers around England and Wales – initially the Society’s membership was to be drawn only from English and Welsh law schools – inviting them to an initial meeting. One of the recipients of that letter was Arthur Chapman at the University of Leeds. He replied: ‘I suppose there is no danger of such an organisation in the end imposing upon the various Schools of Law one rigid pattern of abstraction or one inflexible list of subjects.’ Chapman was worried about his professional autonomy. Jenks replied by suggesting that there was a far greater chance of such standardisation of legal education in the absence of an ‘organ which can utter a protest on behalf of the only persons who are really competent to speak on the question.’ That quickly allayed Chapman’s concerns and nothing more was heard about the matter. That concern for professional autonomy is one, however, to which we can all still relate. Universities’ attempts to control what we do, by when and how we do it are getting ever more stringent. We have also recently seen reforms to professional legal education in the form of the Solicitors’ Qualifying Examination (SQE) and changes to the ways one qualifies for the Bar. It is no secret that aspects of those changes came in for considerable criticism from a variety of quarters, but it is that voice, to which Jenks referred, on behalf of its members that the Society of Legal Scholars still has and still uses, in conjunction with its sister organisations – the ALT, SLSA and CHULS, to engage with professional regulators, Research England and other interested bodies.

The President in 2022-2023, Professor Lucy Vickers of Oxford Brookes, quoted in her address at this Reception from a letter by Professor Murison, President in 1916-1917, where he suggested that legal academics should receive a ‘reasonable supplement to the present very insufficient endowments.’ That reminds us that, in very difficult conditions – when many law schools are freezing or withdrawing research support for conferences and when several universities are seeking to make, sometimes sweeping, redundancies – the rumbling dispute about pay and conditions between union and employers is still very much alive, with the possibility of further industrial action in the Autumn. Not all SLS members are members of the union, but we can all agree, I think, on the need for competitive pay and conditions.

The withdrawal or cutting of research support for conferences is another issue of which the Society needs to take account. The need to meet is as important now as it was when Edward Jenks suggested in his initial letter to Walter Copinger that ‘…a society or association of teachers of law be formed, to meet occasionally… in London or some other convenient centre.’ The community of which we are part cannot exist without our being able to meet and discuss our work. The Society is responding to this through its continued commitment to online and hybrid events. The 2024 Baroness Hale Lecture, given by Sir Peter Fraser, the Chair of the Law Commission, at Swansea University was a hybrid event and similar arrangements will be in place for the 2025 Hale Lecture at the University of Stirling. Among other things, we continue to provide support to members, who would otherwise be unable to attend the annual conference, through our Additional Support Fund, and of course continue to make available the facility to present at the conference virtually where necessary.

Reflecting on how things have stayed the same as well as how they have changed reminds us that we do not start from scratch every time we have a new President. I deliberately chose to have no theme for the conference in 2025 to afford myself the ability to pick up themes from earlier conferences. We shall return to the theme of Law and the Public Good from the 2023 conference at Oxford Brookes with a plenary on ‘The Research User: Engagement, Impact and Co-Creation’ where we explore ways in which academic research is used by a variety of – to use the dreaded jargon – ‘stakeholders’. We will also pick up on the theme, from the 2024 conference at Bristol, under the Presidency of Professor Paula Giliker, of Learning from Others with a plenary on ‘Interdisciplinary Approaches and Methodologies in Law’ where we reflect on how law learns from and engages with other disciplines and methodologies. I am sure the subject sections will produce their normal exciting and diverse programmes, covering the broad sweep of our common subject of law. We have an engaging set of social events, including the annual dinner to be held at the Royal Armouries with an opportunity to look around one of its galleries over pre-dinner drinks. Leeds is a buzzing and exciting city, and I look forward to seeing as many of you as possible in September at the University of Leeds for the Society’s 116th annual conference.

Professor Duncan Sheehan

SLS President (2024-2025)