Home > Speech at President’s Reception 2023

Speech at President’s Reception 2023

It is a huge honour to be President of the SLS this year. I have been involved with the SLS for pretty much the whole of my career, attending my first conference nearly 30 years ago under the presidency of Professor John Tiley.

But of course my association with the law predates this, having come to an academic career after a short spell in legal practice during which time I learnt a huge amount about the practice of law, and fulfilled my early ambition to work as a lawyer. While my choice of a legal career was perhaps not a surprise for those I grew up with, who will have been aware of my tendency to argue back (working in the law, this tendency becomes a strength, and can be reframed as an ability to ‘present a counter argument’!) I think I am as surprised as anyone else about the way my career has progressed to the point that I am giving this speech today.

Certainly the founders of the SLS would likely be surprised.

As a good academic I started thinking about what I might say this evening with some research, and looked at the history of the society, written in 2009 to celebrate the Society’s centenary. (‘A Great and Noble Occupation’: The History of the Society of Legal Scholars, F Cownie and R Cocks, Hart Publishing, 2009).

It is an interesting read, particularly regarding the early years of this organisation of which I am currently president , but which would not have allowed me as a member at the time. This is not only because membership was limited to men. It took quite a lot of time between women being admitted to the profession (1919) and women being allowed to join the SLS in 1949; but also, because teachers from the ‘new universities’ were not allowed membership until 1990.

Although still very much a minority in terms of presidents, participation in the Society from members of post-92 universities has increased; and differences between the pre- and post-92 universities blurring. Moreover, scores in the latest REF demonstrate, if nothing else does, that there is no clear dividing line in terms of quality of research outputs between post and pre-92s.

So what would the founders have thought of our current SLS? Having noted some things that have changed in terms of who is allowed membership, some things, it seems, don’t change.

The history of the Society contains an interesting discussion of pay in 1917. It includes a quote from early correspondence: ‘Every professional teacher ought to be able, and to be required to do….a ‘day’s work everyday’ at his proper subject. This implies a need for a reasonable supplement to the present very insufficient endowments… unless teachers are put in a position to ‘make a business’ of their work, it is absurd to expect them to cope with the appalling amount of research that is waiting to be done….’

This is the same message, albeit in rather more elaborate language, that is being made today. While not all members of the SLS are union members, most agree with the need for sufficient pay to attract the next generation of legal academics into the profession; and the need for sufficient time to undertake the ‘appalling amount of research waiting to be done’!

Moreover,we recognise that the same may be said for areas of legal practice which currently also might be able to claim that they receive ‘insufficient endowments’. Again, there are vital areas of the profession where sufficient pay is needed to attract the next generation to join the profession.

Returning to the Society’s history: The SLS was founded as an association of law teachers, rather grandly termed in early correspondence: ‘a great and noble occupation’.

While that terminology does feel rather grandiose to modern ears, I think it is something we should hold on to. The ‘occupation’ referred to was that of academic lawyers, but I think in the context of the President’s reception we can be prepared to share it. This is even more the case when we think about how lawyers and even the rule of law have been subject to significant criticism in recent years.

It used to be the case that law was perhaps seen as a rather boring subject. But recently, lawyers have been branded as ‘experts’ as if that is a term of abuse rather than professional pride; and with the government openly accepting that it may be acceptable to ignore international law, law and lawyers no longer seem to be boring. Indeed, educating the next generation of lawyers starts to sound quite a radical act! As with the membership issue, this is not perhaps what the founders might have expected.

This brings me to the theme of the next SLS annual conference. When I chose the theme Law and the Public Good for the 2023 conference, I was aware that it might be something of a cliché, with its overtones of a UCAS personal statement. But I was keen to find a theme that would unite some of the speakers I wanted to invite. This includes an eminent panel of judges, as well as Joss Saunders who set up Lawyers against Poverty with Oxfam, the Oxford-based charity.  Lawyers Against Poverty  is a community of lawyers tackling social inequality by supporting strategic legal interventions to alleviate poverty worldwide.

While I chose the theme as a way to bring together a range of speakers doing important work, more recently the topic has become extremely important in the light of recent attacks on lawyers and the rule of law. In this context, a reminder of the role of law, as well as roles of practising lawyers and legal academics, as being on the side of the public good feels less like a platitude and a bit more radical.

Given the current challenges facing our professions it is particularly important for us lawyers to stick together, and that is why evenings such as the President’s reception are so important. It allows us to host this reception for lawyers in all their variety. Whether you are a lawyer from private practice, or from the public sector, a judge, legal educator, or legal reformer, or engaged in research which develops our understanding of the law and its reform, we are all engaged in the ‘noble occupation’ of which the SLS founders would be proud.

Professor Lucy Vickers, SLS President 2022-23